Reviewer:radbooks Date:10/17/05
I enjoyed this, it was funny and I got a lot of quiet laughs while reading it. I am sure that it speaks to most fan fiction writers on many different levels. While Gildor is not my personal dream - a certain scruffy ranger from the north is - I also wouldn't mind if he showed up here! :) Thanks for sharing and I can't wait for the next installment.
Report this review, 515, for abuse of site guidelines.
[2] Strange Encounters by:Soledad
Reviewer:bardess Date:10/17/05
Oh, thrice funny vignettes. 1. Your RL computer and teacher issues are very wry. 2. Your characterizations are original 3. Your 'dialog' with other fanfic writers is witty. I have read some of your stories and will be sure to read more.
Report this review, 516, for abuse of site guidelines.
[3] Strange Encounters by:Soledad
Reviewer:Rebecca Date:10/19/05
1. You have a terrific sense of humor
2. If your given name is either of the two I'm guessing, I think it's a lovely name, but then I've never been too fond of my own so I can commiserate.
3. I once offered you some nit-picking feedback, but only because I was so sucked into your story (because it was very well conceived & written!) that the little thing I noticed was jarring. I don't know about other people, but I don't give any feedback at all to people whose writing seems hopeless or not worth the effort to comment on.
4. Keep it up! Elrond in particular was really really funny -- I thought the same thing about the movie Imladris.
Rants are such fun to read ... when they're articulate!
Report this review, 519, for abuse of site guidelines.
[4] Strange Encounters by:Soledad
Reviewer:mk Date:11/08/05
reading about all the visitors to your realm makes me feel lonely.
I trust the poisonous plotcritters have been kept at bay.
I look forward to reading more of your tales.
In these, I must say, Glorfindel stands out and young Estel. Thank you for the pleasant views of them.
mk
Report this review, 532, for abuse of site guidelines.